The Path to WWE: Why Samoa Joe and Finn Bálor Went Through NXT While AJ Styles Got Direct Entry
When WWE signs new talent, the choice of whether to send them to developmental wrestling shows like NXT or give them a direct entry to the main roster can significantly impact their career trajectory. This article explores the reasons behind the decision for A.J. Styles, Samoa Joe, and Finn Bálor, focusing on the unique circumstances that led to their respective paths.
Why A.J. Styles Got Direct Entry to SmackDown Royal Rumble
A.J. Styles, a prominent figure in professional wrestling, had a high profile when he first signed with WWE. His career in Total Nonstop Action Wrestling (TNA) included holding the Intercontinental title, which solidified his status as a major player in the industry. In contrast, while Finn Bálor was well-respected in New Japan Pro-Wrestling (NJPW), he had not held any major titles, and Samoa Joe had not held a major title for some time before joining WWE.
Given that Styles was already a household name, there was no need for the WWE to introduce him gradually through NXT. Additionally, Styles had significant experience with the TV style of wrestling, making a direct entry more suitable for him. The higher-ups felt that with his recognition and past experience, Styles could immediately contribute to the network's roster with an established fan base.
Case for Finn Bálor's Developmental Journey
Finn Bálor's entry into WWE presented a different set of challenges. Although he was highly respected in Japan and on the overseas independent scene, his initial fame in the United States was limited to dedicated wrestling fans. Because WWE did not want to introduce him to a mainstream audience prematurely, sending Bálor through NXT served as a strategic move to boost the profile of the developmental brand. This approach helped to attract new fans while simultaneously transitioning Bálor to a more polished and marketable performer.
Moreover, Bálor needed time to adjust to the WWE format, which differs from the fast-paced, spot-heavy independent matches he was used to. The developmental environment allowed Bálor to refine his skills and gain the mental fortitude required for WWE level competition.
Samoa Joe's Role in NXT's Revival
Samoa Joe's journey through WWE showcased a different necessity for the developmental system. Upon his initial signing, Joe's in-ring style and name recognition were strong enough to immediately contribute to the main roster. However, it was more of a need for NXT than a need for Joe, as the developmental brand was in urgent need of a charismatic leader.
NXT was depleted of top talent at the time, and both Kevin Owens and Sami Zayn had already departed for the main roster. Balor was also starting his transition. The brand needed a figurehead to revitalize interest and provide hope and inspiration to the fanbase. Samo Joe and Shinsuke Nakamura were the primary representatives of this new era, and their presence kept NXT afloat during difficult times.
Conclusion: A Balanced Approach
The decision to have A.J. Styles, Samoa Joe, and Finn Bálor go through NXT or get direct entry to the main roster reflects a multifaceted strategy in WWE. Each wrestler's path was tailored to their specific needs and the developmental landscape at the time. Styles was given the immediate spotlight due to his high profile, while Bálor and Joe were given the nurturing environment of NXT for different reasons. These strategic moves underscore the importance of a well-planned path in shaping the careers of new WWE talent.